Seed 4
Prince Street Pizza
Nolita
Nolita. Square Sicilian, pepperoni that cups into little grease cups. The Spicy Spring is the one people cross town for, then post.
Popularity89.3
Taste40.4
Online79.3
Final69.7
StyleSicilian square slice
Signature pieSpicy Spring
Address27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
Instagram230,000
The receipts
Stars and counts as sourced on 11 Nov 2026. A missing platform was left out, not scored as zero.
MenuToEat reprint. Page updated 19 Apr 2026, so the count may have grown.
Critics
None in the taste pillar for this shop.
On the record
The Yelp Elites list sits in the online-presence pillar of the field model, not the taste pillar. Taste here is stars only.