Seed 8
Lucali
Carroll Gardens
575 Henry, Carroll Gardens. Cash only, BYOB, candlelight, one room. A basil pie people wait hours for. The heavyweight of the eight on Instagram.
Popularity79.1
Taste37.2
Online80.5
Final65.6
StyleThin-crust whole pie. Cash only, BYOB.
Signature pieClassic three-cheese pie with basil
Address575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Instagram284,232
The receipts
Stars and counts as sourced on 11 Nov 2026. A missing platform was left out, not scored as zero.
OpenPizzaMap reprint of Google.